Woodland Creation – Diverse Conifer

This is an old version of the page

This is an old version of the page

Date published: 2 July, 2015

Date superseded: 16 July, 2015

Updates to last version

  • addition of scoring criteria

To create conifer woodlands on land that is suitable for timber production and that is accessible for timber transport (including links to suitable public roads).

This option is aimed at planting conifer species other than Sitka spruce.

You must meet all eligibility criteria listed in the Woodland Creation page and:

  • you must comply with the UK Forestry Standard
  • the minimum planting width is 15 metres
  • the minimum block size is two hectares in any one year.
  • you must use at least two conifer species, e.g. Scots pine, Douglas fir, Norway spruce and larch
  • your application must meet the species composition criteria in the table below

Composition of diverse conifer woodland
Item Minimum
(per cent)		Maximum
(per cent)		Minimum stocking density
on the planted area
at year five (per hectare)
Main conifer species [1]40752500
Other conifer species [1]10402500
Native broadleaves or shrubs5101100
Designed open ground [2]010n/a
[1] An intimate mixture of conifers is allowed but the choice of species must meet the requirements of 'species selection'.
[2] You must refer to the designed open ground guidance on the Forestry Commission Scotland Technical Support page to see how designed open ground will apply to your application. For example additional open ground, in excess of the specified percentage, may be permissible depending on the specifics of the site, but will not be eligible for grant support.

Please note that in order to achieve 100 per cent from the table above you will not be able to select all minimum or all of the maximum values.

Species selection

As an initial first step in determining whether or not the site is climatically suitable, you should view the Forestry Grant Scheme (2014–2020) Site Suitability folder on the Forestry Commission Scotland Map Viewer page.

Any applications that are not shown as being climatically suitable will only be considered if you can clearly demonstrate that the site is suitable for the chosen species of trees, for example where there is localised shelter in an otherwise exposed location.

As per the eligibility criteria of the Woodland Creation general guidance the tree species must be 'suitable' or 'very suitable' to the site and have the capacity to achieve the following minimum average yield classes across the application area:

  • yield class 8 for Scots pine and larch
  • yield class 12 for Norway spruce, Douglas fir, western red cedar and other conifer species

Threshold score = 10 points

Each option within your application must meet the threshold score to be considered for approval. In achieving the threshold score, your option must score against each criterion except for Additional Benefit.

The scores will then be used as the basis for allocating funding on a competitive basis through the Forestry Grant Scheme clearing process.

Delivery of option benefits

1 POINT – for applications that meet the eligibility criteria but do not deliver any of the benefits below

3 POINTS - for applications that provide one or more of the following in addition to meeting the eligibility requirements:

  • applications that will improve an existing afforested landscape by helping to resolve recognised design deficiencies (usually related to the design principles of relative scale and shape)

Or

Or

  • applications that demonstrate further diversification by integrating at least one other appropriate Woodland Creation option (see explanation below) within the scheme boundary (but not Sitka spruce)

Example for 3 points

The total area of the other options must equate to at least 10 per cent of the area of the main Diverse Conifer option or the minimum block size for the other option, whichever is the greater.

20ha Diverse Conifer x 10% = 2ha

20ha Diverse Conifer and 2ha Broadleaves’

Total application = 22ha

5 POINTS - for applications that meet one of the three-point criteria above and one or more of the criteria below:

  • applications which are significant in scale, that consider the impact of timber transport on public highways and are supported by an ‘agreed route’ for timber transport

Or

  • applications that clearly support the aims of National Parks and National Scenic Areas

Or

  • applications within one of the priority areas identified in the FCS-SEPA opportunity mapping projects as likely to provide multiple benefits for natural flood management and water quality. Select the ‘FGS (2014-20) Target Areas’ folder on the FCS Map Viewer to confirm your application meets this requirement.

Scale of Delivery

1 POINT - for applications between 2ha and 4.99ha

3 POINTS - for applications between 5ha and 19.99ha

5 POINTS - for applications above 20ha

Delivering better quality

1 POINT – for applications that meet the minimum diversity eligibility criteria for this option, which is:

  • 5 per cent Native broadleaves and 10 per cent other conifer species

3 POINTS – for applications that deliver more than the minimum diversity eligibility criteria for this option, which is:

  • 10 per cent Native broadleaves and 10 per cent other conifer species

Or

  • 5 per cent Native broadleaves and 25 per cent other conifer species

5 POINTS – for applications that deliver the maximum diversity eligibility criteria for this option, which is:

  • 10 per cent Native broadleaves and 40 per cent other conifer species

Delivery of Good Practice

1 POINT – for applications which meet the minimum relevant industry standards, but do not deliver any of the benefits detailed below.

3 POINTS – for applications that meet one of the criteria detailed below:

  • applications which demonstrate that you have liaised with consultees, communities and neighbours, prior to the scheme being submitted and addressed, where possible, any points they may have raised

5 POINTS – for applications that meet one of the criteria detailed below:

  • applications which clearly demonstrate you have thoroughly assessed the site conditions and propose the most appropriate management techniques to minimise the impacts to the environment. This must be beyond what you might be compelled to do within the conditions of the contract or recognised as an industry standard practice

Or

  • applications which are community owned, led, or supported and clearly demonstrate the delivery of significant benefits to the local community such as designed landscape

Value for Money

Applications where the cost of ancillary eligible capital supporting works, for example: fencing, gates, tree shelters, bracken control, are:

1 POINT - for more than 30 per cent of the total capital cost for initial planting.

Example for 1 point

Core capital item:

Initial planting 2ha Diverse Conifer=£4,320.

Ancillary capital items:

Deer Fence: 600m x £6.80 =£4,080
Deer Gate: 1 x £172 =£172
Rabbit Proofing: 600m x £1.52 =£912
Badger Gate: 2 x £64 =£128


Ancillary costs as a percentage of total grant sought:

£5,292÷£4,320 =123%

3 POINTS - for less than 30 per cent of the total capital cost for initial planting

5 POINTS - for less than 10 per cent of the total capital cost for initial planting

Supplementary point - additional benefit

1 POINT – will be awarded, as an additional point, where:

  • applications are in an area identified as ‘preferred’ within the relevant Forestry and Woodland Strategy (or equivalent)

Click 'Download this page' to create a printable version of this guidance you can save or print out.